Why our sleep experts loved it
Introduction
The quest for the perfect pillow is a journey everyone embarks upon, guided by the desire to enhance the quality of our sleep and our waking hours. Our path has led us to the Staples and Co Goose Down Surround Pillow, an offering that promises balance between softness, support and breathability. As sleep enthusiasts and career mattress reviewers, we are accustomed to lofty promises. Yet, we approached the Staples & Co pillow with a healthy dose of skepticism. After all, is it not common to be disillusioned by overpriced commodities that fail to deliver?
Design and features
Intrigue for the Staples & Co Goose Down Surround Pillow begins with the 233-thread count 100% cotton cover. The crisp and elegant exterior was made to enhance breathability, a refreshing departure from the average pillow. Machine washable at 40 degrees on a synthetic cycle, the elegance of this cover doesn't compromise its practicality. The Pillow comes delivered in a reusable material bag, eschewing plastic packaging in a nod to eco-consciousness.
Construction
Peeking under the classic cotton design, we're greeted with an interesting combination of a goose down and goose feather outer with a goose feather core. The 55% goose down and 45% goose feathers make up a luxurious outer layer that's imagined to provide a sumptuous surface. Underneath this surface, the 100% goose feather core asserts itself - renowned for their conformity to the head and neck. Yet, there was an underlying dose of skepticism inherent to this channel of thought, stemming from our knowledge that feathers can flatten quickly, leading to a loss of support over time.
Additionally, it is important to mention that the fillings have been ethically sourced, approved by the Responsible Down Standard. This ensures the humane treatment of the birds, a delightful reassurance for the ethical consumer. However, one cannot dismiss concerns towards allergies since down, regardless of its source, can still cause allergic reactions.
Suitability
The Staples & Co. Goose Down Surround Pillow receives a medium support firmness rating and medium height, making it suitable for all sleep positions. This may seem like a positive attribute at an initial glance. However, upon closer inspection, it disconcertingly blankets all sleep styles under a uniform umbrella. Side sleepers, stomach sleepers, and back sleepers all have unique needs that may not be universally met by a medium support pillow.
What customers thought
In our quest for an accurate appraisal, we have looked at various customer reviews, discerning the consensus among those who have wrapped their dreams around this pillow. The reviews, while mixed, reveal consensus towards it being overpriced for its level of performance.
Customers have admitted to the initial lure of the pillow's goose feather composition, combined with the promise of a down cover. However, some customers have reported back with disappointments over the pillow's maintenance. Washing the pillow might seem like an easy task due to its machine washability, but in actuality, customers have reported it to be quite fragile to maintain. This clearly isn't a pillow for those who value easy care and durability.
The verdict
So, does the Staples & Co. Down Surround Pillow justify its price tag? Given the experiences of customers, combined with our own in-store testing observations, we maintain our skepticism.
The allure of a cotton-cased, goose feather and down pillow is undeniable. Equally undeniable, however, is the fact that this can be classed within the premium range in terms of price. We found it hard to reconcile the cost with the somewhat average performance. Despite the elegant design and seemingly luxury features, the pressure for it to consistently deliver high performance was not met.
The pillow is, quite simply, oversold in what it promises and underperforms in what it delivers. Medium firmness can be a lackluster experience for those requiring more specific, tailored support. Further, the issue of maintenance fragility coupled with a propensity to trigger allergies adds to the list of obstacles in our endorsement of this product. Most perturbing was the observance of the pillow’s tendency to flatten quickly, revealing a fleeting encounter with the comfort it initially provides.
With the myriad of pillows available within the market, the Staples & Co. Goose Down Surround Pillow does not distinctly stand out. Its features, while impressive on paper, fail to translate effectively into real-world application. In the realm of sleep, where comfort should be king, this pillow abdicates its throne all too quickly. For these reasons, despite its nominal appeal, our recommendation to potential buyers is to proceed with caution, or perhaps, explore other avenues in this vast marketplace.
Remember, the best pillow is not just about the price tag or the promise, but about its ability to deliver satisfying, personalized comfort for your unique way of sleep. Don't let any pillow, including this one, lead you to compromise on that.
Why you can trust WantMattress
We spend hours testing (and/or researching) every product or service we review, so you can be sure you’re buying the best. Find out more about
how we test.
