Why our sleep experts loved it
Today's product under review is one that's endeared itself to the hearts of sleep enthusiasts across the UK - the Staples All Seasons Pillow - a rather intriguing contraption that promises optimal comfort throughout the calendar's twelve turns. However, as we've found in the mattress industry, promises are a dime a dozen. So, we at WantMattress decided to put this hyped-up pillow to the test, scrutinising it from the fluff down to the fibre. Importantly, our analysis was conducted in the confines of a store rather than the comfort of a home, a limitation we hope to address in future reviews.
Design and Features
At the heart of the Staples All Seasons Pillow is an innovative dual-sided design, earmarked for all-year-round comfort. The concept is uncomplicated: one side of the pillow flaunts a 'cool-to-the-touch' fabric developed to optimise satisfaction during hot nights. The other side exudes a more traditional vibe, draped with a 100% 233 thread count cotton fabric intended for enhanced breathability and balanced tranquillity when the chill sets in.
We have to draw attention to the ostentatious 'cool-to-the-touch' fabric. Ingenious as it may be on paper, our in-store testing led us to dissent from the popular acclaim. It wasn't as effective as we anticipated, struggling to deliver on its promise of coolness. As a somewhat hot sleeper myself, this was mildly disappointing.
Construction
As for the innards of this pillow, it boasts 100% microfibre filling comprised of tiny synthetic ball clusters. This stuffing is famed for maintaining a lightweight yet loftiness that is perfect for ultimate support. However, the lofty grandeur quickly deflates into a no-frills flat pillow after some usage, leaving much to be desired. The resilience of the filling seems to be a casualty of initial comfort.
The design also incorporates a deep mesh border, touted to promote airflow for improved ventilation. It was a mixed bag in our testing, while it did allow for improved airflow, the practicality was overshadowed by the lack of decadence for the extra border.
Suitability
On the brighter side, the Staples All Seasons Pillow seemed to hit a sweet spot with its medium support firmness rating and accommodating height. Whether you're a back, side, or front sleeper, the adaptability is commendable. The accessibility doesn't end there. The pillow is machine washable at 40 degrees which makes the maintenance a breeze. Furthermore, it's delivered in a reusable, plastic-free packaging - a praiseworthy nod towards environmental responsibility.
What Customers Thought
In our efforts to get a thorough understanding of user experiences, we sifted through a plethora of reviews. As comforting as it is to lay back on a plush pillow, it was quite the opposite navigating the labyrinth of opinions.
Conversely, the verdict was clear. While most customers lauded the dual-sided pillow design as a nifty feature, very few could vouch for its year-round efficacy. Reviewers generally concurred with us on the 'cool-to-the-touch' fabric, labeling it as underwhelming for hot sleepers. While it wasn't a red flag, the cotton side didn't garner specific praises either. It served its purpose with adequate breathability but lacked any real luxurious feeling.
The Verdict
As a final thumbs-up, let's commend Staples' earnest offering of a 2-year guarantee, which gives significant peace of mind for investments in our nighttime comfort. When the moon is high in the sky, the last thing you want to worry about is the replacement policy of your pillow!
The Staples All Seasons Pillow is a plausible contender if you are in the market for a medium-support pillow that can take you through the season's shifts with reasonable adaptability. However, much like any "Jack of all trades", it grapples with the inevitable "master of none" conundrum. It promises more than it feasibly delivers, and for some, the dual-sided design might feel more gimmicky than practical.
Perhaps Staples should consider focusing on perfecting one side of the pillow rather than attempting to deliver on both ends, only to land in the lukewarm middle. Despite its shortcomings, we believe Staples has potential, and we keenly anticipate what they have on the cards for future improvement.
In conclusion, the Staples All Seasons Pillow leaves us feeling somewhat flat, echoing the fate of its own microfibre filling. It gives a good shot but falls somewhat short of sweeping us off our feet – or our heads to dreamland, as it were.
Why you can trust WantMattress
We spend hours testing (and/or researching) every product or service we review, so you can be sure you’re buying the best. Find out more about
how we test.
